When we hear the term sex offender, we typically envision a predator: someone who lurks in dark shadows and rapes unsuspecting victims, or who molests and sexually abuses the vulnerable. But here's the truth: a lot of people labeled as sex offenders in Florida are not bad or sick people. They are just like you, me, or close friends/relatives.
All right, all right, calm down and put away your torches and pitchforks. Allow me to explain.
People who have either pled or been found guilty of sexual battery or unlawful sexual activity with certain minors must register as sex offenders. That doesn't sound too unreasonable, right? But under Florida law, a person who is 24 years old is guilty of unlawful sexual activity if that person's partner is 17 years old and they are engaged in an vaginal, oral, or anal penetration with the other person's sex organ. Mutual consent is irrelevant. Yep, that's right, a 24 year old who has consentual oral sex with his/her 17 year old boyfriend/girlfriend is a sex offender in Florida.
Don't think those cases are prosecuted? Think again. All it takes is for someone who has a motive (like, say, Mom and Dad, who have never liked the older partner) or someone who has a duty to report (like a sex education teacher who finds out their student is sexually active with an older partner) to call the police. And once the police are called, they have to make an arrest. And once an arrest is made and that information is sent to the State Attorney's Office, good luck getting a prosecutor to drop a sex offender case. Because, believe me, the State Attorney's Office is politically motivated by the very fact that the State Attorney is an elected position. And there isn't a single State Attorney in Florida who wants a reporter to expose the fact that several sex offender charges were dropped by prosecutors in their office. It doesn't matter if the young couple are engaged to be married and have known each other for years, or that they are consenting to the activity, or that they love each other and are mature, intelligent people. The best you can hope for when an arrest in such a case has been made is that the prosecutor will allow the person to avoid prison time and to receive probation.
But even sex offender probation is different. With the label of being a sex offender, you can't live in a lot of areas, you can't work in a lot of professions, and you can't move without updating the registry in that county. Often times, you have to remain employed as a condition of probation. Good luck getting someone to hire you once you have been labeled a sex offender.
Life becomes incredibly hard once you have that label. You become the person all the neighbors hate. You become the person no one will hire. You become the person no landlord will rent out an apartment to. It is a lifelong designation, and you will be hated and reviled by people who don't know the first thing about you. And why? Because you were 24 when you allowed your 17 year old girlfriend to perform oral sex on you.
Wednesday, December 28, 2011
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Minimum Mandatory Sentences...Or, Why The Legislature Thinks Discretion Is Evil
If you practice criminal defense long enough, you will inevitably end up with a case where your client is facing a minimum mandatory sentence. In Florida, minimum mandatory sentences (or "min mans", as we call them) are sentences where you will serve that prison term day-for-day. No early release. No time off for good behavior. No parole (for the record, Florida did away with parole many years ago). The only way you will get out of custody before each of those days is served is if you die.
So, what's the big deal? If you're facing a mandatory minimum sentence, then you did something horrible and deserve to be locked away for that amount of time, right? Not so. The truth is that Florida imposes mimimum mandatory sentences for a lot of crimes that don't necessarily merit those lengthy prison terms.
Here's an example: If you possess 4 grams or more of oxycodone or hydrocodone without a prescription (in your name), then you face a minimum mandatory sentence of 3 years in prison. How much is 4 grams? Depends on the size of the pills, but it's 20 pills if they are 200 milligrams each, or 8 pills if they are 500 milligrams each. Makes you think twice before putting your mom's small bottle of pain pills in your purse to help you with that horrible toothache, doesn't it?
The worst part about minimum mandatory sentences is that they don't care about your prior record (or lack thereof). You could be arrested for the first time in your entire life, and you will receive the mandatory minimum sentence if you are found guilty or plea to the offense. Now, if you have an extensive criminal history, you may very well receive more than the mandatory minimum. But otherwise, you prior record has zero effect on whether the mandatory minimum sentence will be imposed.
And what about the judge? Sadly, the judge can't do a darn thing about it. Mimum mandatory laws require that a judge sentence a defendant to at least the minimum mandatory term if the defendant either pleads to the charge or is found guilty at trial.
The only person who can waive the minimum mandatory sentence in the prosecutor, as part of a plea bargain. Why the Florida legislature has left this modicum of discretion in the hands of prosecutors is beyond me. Put it in the hands of young lawyers trying to make a name for themselves and probably burdened with the pressure of their office where supervisors want them to take a "hard line on crime"instead of the hands of a seasoned legal veteran who serves terms and takes an oath to be impartial and fair...
Sadly, hundreds (and perhaps thousands) of people plea to crimes they did not commit in exchange for lesser sentences because they know they will serve a minimum amount of mandatory prison if they are found guilty by 6 people they don't know from Adam, even if the judge listens to the case and is sympathetic to the defendant.
So, what's the big deal? If you're facing a mandatory minimum sentence, then you did something horrible and deserve to be locked away for that amount of time, right? Not so. The truth is that Florida imposes mimimum mandatory sentences for a lot of crimes that don't necessarily merit those lengthy prison terms.
Here's an example: If you possess 4 grams or more of oxycodone or hydrocodone without a prescription (in your name), then you face a minimum mandatory sentence of 3 years in prison. How much is 4 grams? Depends on the size of the pills, but it's 20 pills if they are 200 milligrams each, or 8 pills if they are 500 milligrams each. Makes you think twice before putting your mom's small bottle of pain pills in your purse to help you with that horrible toothache, doesn't it?
The worst part about minimum mandatory sentences is that they don't care about your prior record (or lack thereof). You could be arrested for the first time in your entire life, and you will receive the mandatory minimum sentence if you are found guilty or plea to the offense. Now, if you have an extensive criminal history, you may very well receive more than the mandatory minimum. But otherwise, you prior record has zero effect on whether the mandatory minimum sentence will be imposed.
And what about the judge? Sadly, the judge can't do a darn thing about it. Mimum mandatory laws require that a judge sentence a defendant to at least the minimum mandatory term if the defendant either pleads to the charge or is found guilty at trial.
The only person who can waive the minimum mandatory sentence in the prosecutor, as part of a plea bargain. Why the Florida legislature has left this modicum of discretion in the hands of prosecutors is beyond me. Put it in the hands of young lawyers trying to make a name for themselves and probably burdened with the pressure of their office where supervisors want them to take a "hard line on crime"instead of the hands of a seasoned legal veteran who serves terms and takes an oath to be impartial and fair...
Sadly, hundreds (and perhaps thousands) of people plea to crimes they did not commit in exchange for lesser sentences because they know they will serve a minimum amount of mandatory prison if they are found guilty by 6 people they don't know from Adam, even if the judge listens to the case and is sympathetic to the defendant.
Tuesday, November 29, 2011
Should I Hire A Private Attorney?
Being accused of a crime is very serious and the consequences can have a lifelong impact. You could potentially lose your job, you could lose your housing, you could lose some of your rights (voting, possessing a firearm, etc.), and your reputation can be tarnished. It's not the time to sacrifice quality over price.
That isn't to say that public defenders are not quality attorneys. I know a lot of current and former public defenders who are great attorneys, and I'd characterize some of them as better than most private criminal defense attorneys in the central Florida area. I used to be a public defender, and I worked hard for my clients and tried to get the best result for them that I possibly could. I argued tirelessly on their behalf, I put forth their best defense, and I could usually be found in the office on the weekends, or at the jail late at night. However, I was also overloaded with clients. And to be honest, the clients with the most serious charges usually received more of my attention. When you have that many clients, you have to prioritize them. Sad, but true. Not all of my clients received 100% of my attention. It was impossible.
As a private attorney, I naturally have fewer clients and have the time to dedicate myself to each of those clients. I'm able to talk to all of the witnesses in the case, including alleged victims, well ahead of most court dates. I can also take the time to talk to any of my client's family members who are concerned, answer all questions, visit the scene of the alleged offense, run clients through a mock cross examinaiton in anticipation of trial, etc.. Basically, I have the ability to thoroughly examine the case from every angle.
If you have the resources, you should hire a private criminal defense attorney with a good reputation and solid experience. They are worth every penny when your freedom is at stake. If you are accused of a crime, call TSL Defense at 407-412-7040 today to schedule your free consultation.
That isn't to say that public defenders are not quality attorneys. I know a lot of current and former public defenders who are great attorneys, and I'd characterize some of them as better than most private criminal defense attorneys in the central Florida area. I used to be a public defender, and I worked hard for my clients and tried to get the best result for them that I possibly could. I argued tirelessly on their behalf, I put forth their best defense, and I could usually be found in the office on the weekends, or at the jail late at night. However, I was also overloaded with clients. And to be honest, the clients with the most serious charges usually received more of my attention. When you have that many clients, you have to prioritize them. Sad, but true. Not all of my clients received 100% of my attention. It was impossible.
As a private attorney, I naturally have fewer clients and have the time to dedicate myself to each of those clients. I'm able to talk to all of the witnesses in the case, including alleged victims, well ahead of most court dates. I can also take the time to talk to any of my client's family members who are concerned, answer all questions, visit the scene of the alleged offense, run clients through a mock cross examinaiton in anticipation of trial, etc.. Basically, I have the ability to thoroughly examine the case from every angle.
If you have the resources, you should hire a private criminal defense attorney with a good reputation and solid experience. They are worth every penny when your freedom is at stake. If you are accused of a crime, call TSL Defense at 407-412-7040 today to schedule your free consultation.
Tuesday, November 22, 2011
Thanksgiving and Divorce
Now that our family law practice is expanding and the holidays are upon us (is that Christmas music I hear on the radio?), writing a blog about divorce on Thanksgiving seems fitting. This is intended as some friendly advice, but feel free to respond or comment with your own feelings about the issue and let us know if your experience has led you to different conclusions.
Holidays Can Be Stressful, Especially During Divorce
We come to know Thanksgiving as a time of family togetherness steeped in deep traditions. For those currently in the process of a divorce, have recently divorced, or divorced several years ago and remain single while everyone else has coupled up, Thanksgiving can be a very difficult and emotional time. The good news is that you will be surrounded by people who love you and are supportive of you. However, they also aren't mind readers. If you're feeling anxious or sad about the holiday, try letting at least one family member or fellow Thanksgiving dinner attendee know about how your feeling. You'll feel better for getting it off your chest (as opposed to keeping it in and possibly crying into your mashed potatos when someone asks how things are going in your life). You'll also create an ally in the person you've confided in, and he/she will help deflect any comments or questions from others that could potentially rub salt in your wounds.
This is also a good time to connect with those family members who are also single, and have probably been enduring Thanksgiving meals that border on interrogations for years (i.e. "when are you going to settle down and find a good husband/wife?"). These folks know how to cope with Thanksgiving and typically have excellent strategies that you can pick up. I once heard someone say that her Thanksgiving host's dinner table sat twelve people and there were 6 couples coming to Thanksgiving, and so the host seated all the couples at one table and put the others at the "kid's table." However, this person relabeled the "kids table" as the "freedom table" and had a wonderful time with the other single people and the kids, as they would hilariously quote Braveheart during the toasts.
If you're really dreading Thanksgiving with your family and you don't think there's any way to mitigate the stress, try having Thanksgiving with other relatives or with your friends. Not everyone's Thanksgiving is the same and you may be pleasantly surprised at the different traditions other people have. I once had Thanksgiving at a professor's house when I couldn't fly home from college and I had a great time with new people, different food, and good conversation. It was a welcome distraction from the nostalgia. Another thing you can try is treating yourself to a delicious Thanksgiving meal at a nice restaurant. Most fancy restaurants have a special Thanksgiving dinner service with excellent food, and several people in similar situations will be in attendance.
As odd as it may seem, there could be potential upsides to coordinating Thanksgiving post divorce. Often times, married couples have difficulty splitting up the holidays with their respective families. Sometimes, spouses don't get along with their in-laws, and forced get-togethers during the holidays cause fighting and stress. Going through a divorce is very emotional and very hard, but won't it be nice to not have to sit through another holiday dinner with your former in-laws who you've never liked anyway? Small condolences, I know. But worth appreciating, for some.
Custody During The Holidays
Now people going through divorce at Thanksgiving often also have the issue of child custody. It's important to remember that divorce is not only hard on the parents, but it's also hard on the child. Kids are often sad around the holidays because they aren't sharing it with both parents. They family isn't what it used to be, the routine is broken, and the holidays will most likely not be the same. It's natural that they'll be sad, so whatever each parent can do to minimize the sadness is a good idea. Some things you should never do is talk negatively about the other parent in front of the child, or make the child feel guilty about spending the holiday with his/her other parent instead of you. It's immature, and the child will resent you for it. If the child is spending Thanksgiving with you this year and the co-parent calls during dinner to talk to the child for five minutes, let your child take the call. Your ex is probably having a hard time dealing with the child's absence during the holiday, and you will probably want the same courtesy extended to you next year when the child spends Thanksgiving with your ex. If you have your child for the holiday and your child misses a phone call from the co-parent, try to have your child return the phone call promptly.
That being said, the parent who does not have the child for Thanksgiving should respect the family time the other parent is having with the child and be mindful of the duration of any phone calls with the child. In other words, don't talk to your child on the phone for an hour when the child is supposed to be having dinner with his/her other parent, and don't call incessantly. It's rude to interrupt the dinner for that long and you wouldn't want the same treatment. Try to limit the calls to 5 or 10 minutes.
In Florida, time sharing (custody) of the child during the holidays is almost always addressed in any parenting plan agreement filed with the court as a matter of process when a divorce is granted and their are children common to the marriage. Make sure you think about what you want to do during the holidays before you sign any agreement. If the agreement calls for alternating Thanksgiving with each parent every year, does it address whether the child will spend the day before, or after, the holiday with the other parent? Many agreements call for Parent X to have Thanksgiving with the child on even calendar years, with Parent Y to have the child for the next day (Black Friday), and the reverse to occur on odd calendar years. This may seem like a good idea, but it could also limit travel plans on Thanksgiving. If it's your turn to have the child on Thanksgiving, but you want to spend Thanksgiving at your mother's house and she lives 200 miles away, then having the child back to your co-parent's arms the next day will be very difficult. I'm not suggesting someone not sign an agreement that calls for alternating Thanksgiving with the other parent getting Black Friday. After all, your child's right to see both parents should come before your travel plans. I'm simply urging co-parents to think about these things through and through before signing an agreement. If you never travel far on Thanksgiving, or you always host the holiday dinner, then it's a non-issue.
Hopefully, there will be the day when both parents feel welcome to share Thanksgiving together with the child. But that is rarely the case, for various reasons. Divorce is complicated, time sharing is complicated, and the resulting holidays can be as well. Maturity, understanding, and a good attitude can improve the situation. Hopefully, the company you share during the holiday is supportive, and loving, and will help you get through what can be a difficult time. That's what family is for. And that's ultimately what the holiday is about: sharing love, in all its forms. You may not have it romantically, but it is there nonetheless, within your support system.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Holidays Can Be Stressful, Especially During Divorce
We come to know Thanksgiving as a time of family togetherness steeped in deep traditions. For those currently in the process of a divorce, have recently divorced, or divorced several years ago and remain single while everyone else has coupled up, Thanksgiving can be a very difficult and emotional time. The good news is that you will be surrounded by people who love you and are supportive of you. However, they also aren't mind readers. If you're feeling anxious or sad about the holiday, try letting at least one family member or fellow Thanksgiving dinner attendee know about how your feeling. You'll feel better for getting it off your chest (as opposed to keeping it in and possibly crying into your mashed potatos when someone asks how things are going in your life). You'll also create an ally in the person you've confided in, and he/she will help deflect any comments or questions from others that could potentially rub salt in your wounds.
This is also a good time to connect with those family members who are also single, and have probably been enduring Thanksgiving meals that border on interrogations for years (i.e. "when are you going to settle down and find a good husband/wife?"). These folks know how to cope with Thanksgiving and typically have excellent strategies that you can pick up. I once heard someone say that her Thanksgiving host's dinner table sat twelve people and there were 6 couples coming to Thanksgiving, and so the host seated all the couples at one table and put the others at the "kid's table." However, this person relabeled the "kids table" as the "freedom table" and had a wonderful time with the other single people and the kids, as they would hilariously quote Braveheart during the toasts.
If you're really dreading Thanksgiving with your family and you don't think there's any way to mitigate the stress, try having Thanksgiving with other relatives or with your friends. Not everyone's Thanksgiving is the same and you may be pleasantly surprised at the different traditions other people have. I once had Thanksgiving at a professor's house when I couldn't fly home from college and I had a great time with new people, different food, and good conversation. It was a welcome distraction from the nostalgia. Another thing you can try is treating yourself to a delicious Thanksgiving meal at a nice restaurant. Most fancy restaurants have a special Thanksgiving dinner service with excellent food, and several people in similar situations will be in attendance.
As odd as it may seem, there could be potential upsides to coordinating Thanksgiving post divorce. Often times, married couples have difficulty splitting up the holidays with their respective families. Sometimes, spouses don't get along with their in-laws, and forced get-togethers during the holidays cause fighting and stress. Going through a divorce is very emotional and very hard, but won't it be nice to not have to sit through another holiday dinner with your former in-laws who you've never liked anyway? Small condolences, I know. But worth appreciating, for some.
Custody During The Holidays
Now people going through divorce at Thanksgiving often also have the issue of child custody. It's important to remember that divorce is not only hard on the parents, but it's also hard on the child. Kids are often sad around the holidays because they aren't sharing it with both parents. They family isn't what it used to be, the routine is broken, and the holidays will most likely not be the same. It's natural that they'll be sad, so whatever each parent can do to minimize the sadness is a good idea. Some things you should never do is talk negatively about the other parent in front of the child, or make the child feel guilty about spending the holiday with his/her other parent instead of you. It's immature, and the child will resent you for it. If the child is spending Thanksgiving with you this year and the co-parent calls during dinner to talk to the child for five minutes, let your child take the call. Your ex is probably having a hard time dealing with the child's absence during the holiday, and you will probably want the same courtesy extended to you next year when the child spends Thanksgiving with your ex. If you have your child for the holiday and your child misses a phone call from the co-parent, try to have your child return the phone call promptly.
That being said, the parent who does not have the child for Thanksgiving should respect the family time the other parent is having with the child and be mindful of the duration of any phone calls with the child. In other words, don't talk to your child on the phone for an hour when the child is supposed to be having dinner with his/her other parent, and don't call incessantly. It's rude to interrupt the dinner for that long and you wouldn't want the same treatment. Try to limit the calls to 5 or 10 minutes.
In Florida, time sharing (custody) of the child during the holidays is almost always addressed in any parenting plan agreement filed with the court as a matter of process when a divorce is granted and their are children common to the marriage. Make sure you think about what you want to do during the holidays before you sign any agreement. If the agreement calls for alternating Thanksgiving with each parent every year, does it address whether the child will spend the day before, or after, the holiday with the other parent? Many agreements call for Parent X to have Thanksgiving with the child on even calendar years, with Parent Y to have the child for the next day (Black Friday), and the reverse to occur on odd calendar years. This may seem like a good idea, but it could also limit travel plans on Thanksgiving. If it's your turn to have the child on Thanksgiving, but you want to spend Thanksgiving at your mother's house and she lives 200 miles away, then having the child back to your co-parent's arms the next day will be very difficult. I'm not suggesting someone not sign an agreement that calls for alternating Thanksgiving with the other parent getting Black Friday. After all, your child's right to see both parents should come before your travel plans. I'm simply urging co-parents to think about these things through and through before signing an agreement. If you never travel far on Thanksgiving, or you always host the holiday dinner, then it's a non-issue.
Hopefully, there will be the day when both parents feel welcome to share Thanksgiving together with the child. But that is rarely the case, for various reasons. Divorce is complicated, time sharing is complicated, and the resulting holidays can be as well. Maturity, understanding, and a good attitude can improve the situation. Hopefully, the company you share during the holiday is supportive, and loving, and will help you get through what can be a difficult time. That's what family is for. And that's ultimately what the holiday is about: sharing love, in all its forms. You may not have it romantically, but it is there nonetheless, within your support system.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Monday, September 19, 2011
Some Things to Know About DUI in Florida
One of the most popular things I’m asked about when people learn I am a criminal defense attorney is DUI (driving under the influence). I’ve listed a couple of the most common questions and tried to answer them to the best of my ability. Keep in mind that DUI is a very complex area of criminal law, and can make even some of the most seasoned criminal defense attorneys cringe. So here are the questions and responses in no particular order:
1) “So what is considered DUI anyway?”
For starters, it’s a lot more than drunk driving. The law in Florida defines the crime of DUI as operating a vehicle or being in actual physical control of the vehicle while affected by either alcohol, or a drug to the extent that one’s normal faculties are impaired. That definition is a lot broader than you might think upon first glance. First, let’s take the definition of “vehicle.” You’re probably thinking of a car, van, or motorcycle, right? Turns out, you can be arrested for DUI for riding a bicycle under the influence. Don’t believe me? I’ve seen it happen and I’ve defended it. The statute only says “vehicle”, it doesn’t say “motor vehicle.”
Next, let’s look at what substance can be used to find you “under the influence.” We usually think of alcohol, but what about things in your medicine cabinet? You can also be arrested for DUI for being under the influence of something other than alcohol, such as marijuana, sleeping pills, Xanax, or anything that requires a prescription, if it’s found to affect your driving. This can be a very tricky area to defend against because substances may still be in your system, even though you are no longer under their influence. A drug test can find the presence of THC (the psychoactive substance found in marijuana) up to 30 days after inhaling the marijuana smoke, even though the person is clearly no longer the influence of the marijuana (i.e. it still shows up in a drug test even though the high is long gone). The drug tests commonly performed by law enforcement to pin a driver with DUI aren’t going to show the concentration of the drug, and will have no way of showing when the drug was ingested. They will just show the drug is in the driver’s blood system, and that can be enough to convict a driver of DUI.
You can also be arrested for DUI if you aren’t driving. The law allows for people to be arrested and convicted for DUI if they are impaired and are in “actual physical control” of a vehicle. A lot of factors are weighed to determine whether someone is in actual physical control of a vehicle, such as whether the vehicle is turned on, whether the person is in the driver’s seat, whether the car is capable of even being turned on, etc.. I’ve seen someone arrested for DUI who had a few drinks and then got into his car to “sleep it off” before driving. He was asleep in the driver’s seat with the keys in the ignition (car was turned off), and the officer knocked on the window to see if the guy was all right, smelled alcohol on his breath when he answered the officer’s questions, and arrested the vehicle occupant (I refuse to use the term “driver” in this instance) for DUI. To determine whether someone is in actual physical control, some attorneys emphasize location: location of the person in the car, location of the keys, etc.. Some analyze whether the car could have been turned on and driven away by the driver within 10 seconds of waking up. And others like to emphasize whether the car itself was even operable. “Actual physical control” needs to be evaluated on a case by case basis, as the definition can vary from one jurisdiction to another, and all circumstances of the arrest must be examined. Unfortunately, there’s no simple answer that applies to all instances that I can provide here in this blog.
2) “Do I have to take the field sobriety test?”
This is one of the few easy questions to answer. NO, you do not have to take the field sobriety tests. The field sobriety “exercises”, as some like to call them, are entirely optional. The fact that you did not choose to do them during your traffic stop should not be used against you, or even mentioned to the jury, at trial for a DUI (because it is not up to you to prove your innocence, it is up to the State to prove your guilt). You may be thinking, “but if I’m not drunk, why not just pass the silly tests to avoid being arrested, I can remember my ABCs in my sleep!” I wish it were true. But the real truth is that most of the time, the officer has already decided that he/she will arrest you for DUI before you’re even asked to perform the exercises, and now the officer is simply trying to gather as much evidence as possible of your guilt. I’ve never heard of someone telling me he/she impressed the officer so much that the officer let him/her drive away from the traffic stop with a warning to not swerve so much on the road next time.
And here’s why: the field sobriety exercises don’t really measure normal functioning, because they don’t ask you to perform normal tasks. Think about it: do you normally walk heel to toe down a straight line for 10 feet and then turn around on your tip toes and walk heel to toe back? Of course not, you’d look stupid. We walk with our feet spaced apart, so we can maintain our balance when we walk and cover more ground. And we tend to pivot when we turn around, not stand on our toes. Do we normally stand with one foot raised 6 inches off the ground while we silently count to 30 and then put our foot down when we think we’ve reached 30 seconds? No, we stand with both legs on the ground. You could be stone cold sober and not be able to stand on one leg with the other 6 inches off the ground for 30 seconds. It doesn’t mean you are drunk at all if you put down your foot after 15 seconds. Why do we rely on activities that force you to perform abnormal tasks in order to measure whether your normal faculties are impaired? Add the nerves and stress caused by the fact you’ve been pulled over by a cop and asked to stand outside of the car and are under investigation of a crime, and let’s see how well you can keep your balance standing on one leg.
Clearly, I’m getting a little whipped up about this, and have strayed too far from answering the original question.
3) Can I call my lawyer when I’m pulled over and being investigated for DUI?
No, in Florida, you do not have the right to call your attorney in the middle of a traffic stop for possible DUI. You do have the right to speak to your attorney before making any statements to police once you are arrested for DUI, with one exception: responding as to whether you will submit to a test of your breath, blood or urine for the presence of alcohol or other substances.
4) Do I have to submit to a breath, blood or urine test?
If you are arrested for DUI and you were either operating or in actual physical control of a motor vehicle, the answer is yes, by law, you are required to submit to the test. Failure to submit to the test will result in an automatic suspension of your drivers license for 6 months. If you have previously refused to submit to the test during a DUI investigation, then a subsequent refusal is a separate misdemeanor offense. The fact that you have refused to submit to a breath, blood or urine test during the investigation can also be used against you in trial and the prosecutor can argue to the jury that you did not take the test because you knew you were guilty. But wait, you’re saying to yourself, I thought you said I don’t have to prove my innocence! That’s true, except for the fact that by being in actual control of a motor vehicle or driving, you have already given your implied consent to submit to a test. If you read the bottom of your Florida driver’s license, you’ll see some print that basically says by operating a motor vehicle, you consent to any sobriety test required by law (breath/drug test….not the field sobriety exercises). Now, you do not have to submit to the test if you are arrested for DUI and you were riding a bike. The implied consent only applies to the operation of motor vehicles. There is no implied consent for vehicles that do not have a motor because you don’t need a driver’s license to operate a vehicle without a motor. I actually had to argue this point to a prosecutor in front of judge who was clearly exasperated with the prosecutor.
Now, the police can’t actually force you to take the test. If you refuse, then you have refused and they will explain the consequences I’ve mentioned above (automatic driver’s license suspension, a separate criminal offense if it’s your second time, etc). And like I said, the prosecutor can argue that you refused because you knew you were guilty. The decision to take the test is yours, and can have strategic implications either way.
5) Can I get a DUI conviction taken off of my record?
Visit Our Firm's Website Here
Monday, June 20, 2011
What Should I Do During a Traffic Stop?
"You're a lawyer, right? What should I do if I get pulled over by a cop? Do I have to sign the ticket? Do I have to get out of the car if the cop asks me to?" I can't begin to keep track of the number of dinner conversations that begin this way when someone learns what I do for a living. I can't say I blame them, we've all had those experiences with being pulled over and not being quite sure what to say or do in a traffic stop. We often think we can talk our way out of a ticket, and just start blabbing away to the cop. From an attorney's persepective though, talking uncontrollably to the cop is probably one of the worst things you can do.
A traffic stop is a detention by a police officer. It is intended to be brief and to last no longer than it takes to write out the traffic citation (keep in mind that writing the citation includes checking your proof of insurance and car registration as well as the protocol of running your name through their database to make sure you do not have any warrants for your arrest). Once the ticket is written and handed to you, there's no reason you should continue to be detained and you should be free to leave.
Here are some brief, helpful tips to keep in mind if you ever find yourself pulled over by the officer:
-When you see the lights or hear the siren behind you and you realize the officer wants to pull you over, you should pull over as soon as it becomes safe to do so. Sometimes you're on a fast highway and there isn't any space on the side of the road, or it's a dark and poorly lit area and you don't feel safe. That's fine, just turn on your turn signal and slow down your speed so the officer knows you are aware of his/her intent to pull you over and is assured you intend to do so, then stop at the closest exit or business or residential area. You don't want the officer to think you intend to flee or engage in a chase, so do what you can to minimize that perception. Fleeing or attempting to elude a police officer is a crime, so don't do anything like accelerate the car to give the officer reason to arrest you for that once you've been pulled over.
-Remain polite and as calm as you can. You may be running late or otherwise in a hurry to go somewhere but being argumentative or acting nervous will only raise the officer's suspicions that something else besides an expired tag is going on and you'll be kept on the side of the road longer.
-If the officer asks if he/she can search your car, you should polititely say no. There's absolutely nothing wrong with saying no and refusing consent to search your car. A general rule is that police need a warrant to search your car without your consent (there's some exceptions such as the car reaking of burnt marijuana, etc., but I won't go into those exceptions here). You may be thinking "I have nothing to hide in the car, why not let him search the car and get on his good side?". Maybe you're right and you have nothing to hide. However, what if someone who borrowed your car left something behind? Maybe your mom left her prescription pill bottle in your car when she went to the pharmacy, and if the officer finds a controlled substance in the car and you don't have a prescription for it, then you have a boatload of problems including a felony arrest for possession of a controlled substance. You may be laughing and thinking that doesn't really happen, but believe me that it does. I've seen it, and I've defended it. And why put yourself through that embarrasing arrest and trip to the jail? When it comes to requests to search the car, I politely tell officers that I have a policy of not allowing anyone to search my car without a warrant.
-Likewise, the police usually need a warrant to search you or your pockets, etc.. So, you have a right to refuse consent to a search of yourself. This can get tricky because sometimes the line gets blurry between a request and an order from a law enforcement officer. An officer with a gun on his/her holster saying "place both hands on the hood of your car so I can make sure you don't have any weapons, please" doesn't sound much like a request. You can ask the officer if that's an order or a request and let the offier know that you do not consent to a search of yourself without a warrant.
- A lot of us keep our proof of insurance and registration in our glove compartments. A driver suddenly reaching for the glove compartment can make an officer jumpy (he/she doesn't know if you intend to grab a weapon, etc.). If an officer asks you for your registration and you keep it in the glove compartment, it's a good idea to let the officer know that's where you have your documents before you reach for the glove compartment. It also means that if you have anything in your car you do not want an officer to see, you should not keep it in the same place you keep your proof of insurance/car registration. For gun owners out there who travel with their guns in the glove compartment, let the officer know you have a permit to carry a concealed firearm and show it to him/her before you open the glvoebox with the gun. Very few things will make the tension level of a traffic stop skyrocket like the unexpected appearance of a gun.
- There's a misconception out there that signing a traffic ticket admits guilt. If the cop gives you a ticket and asks for your signature, you must sign it if you want to avoid going to jail. Your signature on the ticket is simply a promise that you will either pay the ticket or appear in court to contest it. It's not an admission of guilt, and your signature is mandatory.
-Now what if you are riding a bike, can you you be pulled over? Yes, you can. Most of the traffic laws also apply to bicyclists as well as motor vehicle drivers. For purposes of the statutes (i.e. the laws), a bicycle is considered a vehicle, so act accordingly and stop pedaling if an officer is trying to pull you over.
I'll cover DUI traffic stops on another blog post since there's much more involved.
In closing, I wish I could say that traffic stops are pleasant and that all officers are respectful and professional and that you have no reason to worry as long as you follow my tips. But that's just wishful thinking on my part. Some officers will frisk you and search your car for no good reason and without your consent because they want to see if they can make a drug bust, or they'll pull you over and accuse you of going 103 mph on the turnpike when you were going 75 mph. In those situations, be as polite as you can while articulating your lack of consent. It may result in a bum traffic ticket or being kept on the side of the road for 45 minutes. But at least you will avoid arrest for not letting the injustice of the situation get to your temper and emotions. You can dispute the ticket or make a formal complaint against the officer, or any number of remedies after you are allowed to leave. But you'll spare yourself the arrest, bail money, and expense of hiring a lawyer.
A traffic stop is a detention by a police officer. It is intended to be brief and to last no longer than it takes to write out the traffic citation (keep in mind that writing the citation includes checking your proof of insurance and car registration as well as the protocol of running your name through their database to make sure you do not have any warrants for your arrest). Once the ticket is written and handed to you, there's no reason you should continue to be detained and you should be free to leave.
Here are some brief, helpful tips to keep in mind if you ever find yourself pulled over by the officer:
-When you see the lights or hear the siren behind you and you realize the officer wants to pull you over, you should pull over as soon as it becomes safe to do so. Sometimes you're on a fast highway and there isn't any space on the side of the road, or it's a dark and poorly lit area and you don't feel safe. That's fine, just turn on your turn signal and slow down your speed so the officer knows you are aware of his/her intent to pull you over and is assured you intend to do so, then stop at the closest exit or business or residential area. You don't want the officer to think you intend to flee or engage in a chase, so do what you can to minimize that perception. Fleeing or attempting to elude a police officer is a crime, so don't do anything like accelerate the car to give the officer reason to arrest you for that once you've been pulled over.
-Remain polite and as calm as you can. You may be running late or otherwise in a hurry to go somewhere but being argumentative or acting nervous will only raise the officer's suspicions that something else besides an expired tag is going on and you'll be kept on the side of the road longer.
-If the officer asks if he/she can search your car, you should polititely say no. There's absolutely nothing wrong with saying no and refusing consent to search your car. A general rule is that police need a warrant to search your car without your consent (there's some exceptions such as the car reaking of burnt marijuana, etc., but I won't go into those exceptions here). You may be thinking "I have nothing to hide in the car, why not let him search the car and get on his good side?". Maybe you're right and you have nothing to hide. However, what if someone who borrowed your car left something behind? Maybe your mom left her prescription pill bottle in your car when she went to the pharmacy, and if the officer finds a controlled substance in the car and you don't have a prescription for it, then you have a boatload of problems including a felony arrest for possession of a controlled substance. You may be laughing and thinking that doesn't really happen, but believe me that it does. I've seen it, and I've defended it. And why put yourself through that embarrasing arrest and trip to the jail? When it comes to requests to search the car, I politely tell officers that I have a policy of not allowing anyone to search my car without a warrant.
-Likewise, the police usually need a warrant to search you or your pockets, etc.. So, you have a right to refuse consent to a search of yourself. This can get tricky because sometimes the line gets blurry between a request and an order from a law enforcement officer. An officer with a gun on his/her holster saying "place both hands on the hood of your car so I can make sure you don't have any weapons, please" doesn't sound much like a request. You can ask the officer if that's an order or a request and let the offier know that you do not consent to a search of yourself without a warrant.
- A lot of us keep our proof of insurance and registration in our glove compartments. A driver suddenly reaching for the glove compartment can make an officer jumpy (he/she doesn't know if you intend to grab a weapon, etc.). If an officer asks you for your registration and you keep it in the glove compartment, it's a good idea to let the officer know that's where you have your documents before you reach for the glove compartment. It also means that if you have anything in your car you do not want an officer to see, you should not keep it in the same place you keep your proof of insurance/car registration. For gun owners out there who travel with their guns in the glove compartment, let the officer know you have a permit to carry a concealed firearm and show it to him/her before you open the glvoebox with the gun. Very few things will make the tension level of a traffic stop skyrocket like the unexpected appearance of a gun.
- There's a misconception out there that signing a traffic ticket admits guilt. If the cop gives you a ticket and asks for your signature, you must sign it if you want to avoid going to jail. Your signature on the ticket is simply a promise that you will either pay the ticket or appear in court to contest it. It's not an admission of guilt, and your signature is mandatory.
-Now what if you are riding a bike, can you you be pulled over? Yes, you can. Most of the traffic laws also apply to bicyclists as well as motor vehicle drivers. For purposes of the statutes (i.e. the laws), a bicycle is considered a vehicle, so act accordingly and stop pedaling if an officer is trying to pull you over.
I'll cover DUI traffic stops on another blog post since there's much more involved.
In closing, I wish I could say that traffic stops are pleasant and that all officers are respectful and professional and that you have no reason to worry as long as you follow my tips. But that's just wishful thinking on my part. Some officers will frisk you and search your car for no good reason and without your consent because they want to see if they can make a drug bust, or they'll pull you over and accuse you of going 103 mph on the turnpike when you were going 75 mph. In those situations, be as polite as you can while articulating your lack of consent. It may result in a bum traffic ticket or being kept on the side of the road for 45 minutes. But at least you will avoid arrest for not letting the injustice of the situation get to your temper and emotions. You can dispute the ticket or make a formal complaint against the officer, or any number of remedies after you are allowed to leave. But you'll spare yourself the arrest, bail money, and expense of hiring a lawyer.
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
Welcome
Welcome to all of you in the blogosphere reading this. This blog is intended to be a place where you can find information about all aspects of criminal defense. Some information will be useful to those who have been arrested, some will be useful to those hoping to avoid arrest, and some will be useful to those practicing in the area of criminal defense. If you have questions about anything you read in this blog, feel free to respond and comment. Please note, however, that reading this blog does NOT constitute an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, you should not respond or comment with things that you would like to be kept confidential. It's the INTERNET, and what you post on here is accessible to the public. So don't put anything on here you don't want the public to know. If you put "I was recently arrested for DUI, and I blew a .20 on the breath test, but I only had 3 shots of tequila before I drove. What should I do?" Then you have now admitted to having 3 shots of tequila and you have admitted to driving that night. Not smart. Don't comment with facts about your own case. Your comments are not confidential. Pick up the phone and call our law office at (407) 494-2053 and ask for a consultation. This blog is not an appropriate place to have a consultation. Simple enough, right?
Ok, now that the disclaimer is out of the way, I hope you will continue to visit this blog to read up on what's going on in the world of criminal defense and how it can affect you. Enjoy!
Ok, now that the disclaimer is out of the way, I hope you will continue to visit this blog to read up on what's going on in the world of criminal defense and how it can affect you. Enjoy!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)